Estoppel Certificates in Commercial Real Estate Transactions

The Importance of Estoppel Certificates in Commercial Real Estate Transactions

/by

When a commercial property is sold or refinanced, tenants are often asked to sign an estoppel certificate to confirm the key details of the lease such as the rent, lease terms, and any outstanding obligations. Although it might appear like just another formality, an estoppel certificate can impact your rights as a tenant, especially if there are any inaccuracies or omissions. To avoid any unintended consequences, it is important to get the certificate reviewed by an experienced California real estate lawyer and make sure that your rights and interests are fully protected.

What is an Estoppel Certificate?

An estoppel certificate is a legally binding document used in commercial real estate transactions to verify the terms and conditions of an existing lease agreement. It is typically requested by landlords, buyers, or lenders during the sale or refinancing of a commercial property. The purpose of the estoppel certificate is to provide a clear and accurate picture of the tenant’s lease arrangement and make sure that all parties involved in the transaction are fully informed of the property’s financial and legal standing.

Key Components of an Estoppel Certificate

Lease Details in an Estoppel Certificate

  • The date the lease was executed and any subsequent amendments or extensions.
  • The duration of the lease, including the start and end dates.
  • Options to renew or extend the lease, if applicable.

Rent Information

  • The current amount of rent, payment frequency (monthly or annually), and due dates.
  • Details about any rent increases specified in the lease.
  • Confirmation of whether rent is current or if there is any rent amount due.

Security Deposits in an Estoppel Certificate

  • The amount of security deposit paid by the tenant.
  • Confirmation of whether the security deposit has been returned, applied, or remains held by the landlord.

Outstanding Obligations

  • A statement indicating whether the landlord or tenant has unmet obligations under the lease.
  • Any pending disputes, claims, or notices between the landlord and tenant.

Property Condition and Maintenance in an Estoppel Certificate

  • Confirmation of whether the tenant is aware of any existing property defects or maintenance issues.
  • Acknowledgment of who is responsible for ongoing maintenance and repairs as per the lease agreement.

Rights and Restrictions

  • Confirmation of whether the tenant has subleased or assigned the premises to another party.
  • Confirmation of any exclusive rights, such as parking spaces, signage, or use restrictions, granted to the tenant.

No Defaults

  • A statement from the tenant confirming that neither party is in default under the lease.
  • If defaults exist, they should be disclosed along with any steps taken to resolve them.

Tenant Certification

  • A signature from the tenant certifying that the information provided is accurate to the best of their knowledge.

Why You Should Be Careful While Signing an Estoppel Certificate

When you sign an estoppel certificate, you are certifying that the information it contains is accurate and complete. This certification is not something you can easily undo. In California, courts often treat the statements made in an estoppel certificate as definitive, even if they conflict with the terms of your original lease.

For example, if the certificate incorrectly states a higher rent amount or omits a lease renewal option, you might lose the ability to enforce the original terms. This legally binding nature makes it imperative to carefully review the document and ensure every detail aligns with your lease agreement.

Common Mistakes and Omissions in an Estoppel Certificate That Can Affect Your Rights as a Tenant

Inaccurate Rent Details

Any errors related to rent – including the rent amount, payment schedule, or due date – can lead to financial disputes with the landlord. If the rent amount mentioned in the estoppel certificate is different from what is mentioned in your original lease agreement or if the certificate omits details like a rent concession, you might have to pay more than you actually owe. Additionally, incorrect payment terms can cause confusion about when payments are due and potentially expose you to unnecessary penalties.

Omission of Lease Renewal or Extension Rights

Leaving out lease renewal or extension options included in your original lease agreement can jeopardize your right to remain in the property beyond the current lease term. A new landlord or buyer might refuse to honor these rights if they are not documented in the estoppel certificate, as a result of which your lease could be terminated.

Failure to Disclose Unresolved Disputes

When an estoppel certificate omits ongoing disputes or unresolved obligations, such as pending repairs or agreed-upon concessions, you might lose the right to enforce these issues later. Signing a certificate that inaccurately represents the lease as being in good standing can absolve the landlord of obligations that have yet to be fulfilled.

Misrepresentation of Lease Modifications or Amendments

Any amendments or negotiated changes to the lease, such as adjusted rent terms or additional rights, must be accurately reflected in the estoppel certificate. If these are omitted, disputes can arise over which version of the lease is enforceable. Courts or new landlords might rely on the estoppel certificate over the original lease, potentially voiding any unacknowledged modifications.

Inaccurate Statements about Property Conditions

An estoppel certificate that fails to mention existing issues with the property, such as maintenance concerns or unfulfilled landlord responsibilities, can cause problems down the line. New property owners or lenders might assume that the premises are in good condition and refuse to address these issues, as a result of which you might have to handle them yourself.

Incorrect Start and End Dates of the Lease

Mistakes in the start and end dates of the lease term can create confusion about your tenancy’s duration. For instance, an incorrect expiration date could lead to disputes about whether you are still within the lease term or operating as a holdover tenant, which can potentially expose you to eviction or additional charges.

Subleasing or Assignment Rights Not Included

Subleasing or assignment rights, if granted under your lease, must be included in the estoppel certificate. Omitting these rights can result in restrictions on your ability to sublease or transfer the lease, even though your original agreement allows it.

Failure to Account for Exclusive Use Clauses

Exclusive use clauses, such as rights to specific parking spaces, signage, or restricted common areas, should be clearly documented in the estoppel certificate. If these rights are omitted, new landlords might refuse to honor them, which can undermine your right to use and enjoy the premises.

How an Experienced California Real Estate Lawyer Can Help You with an Estoppel Certificate

Reviewing the Certificate for Accuracy

Your lawyer can compare the estoppel certificate with your original lease agreement and review the terms to make sure every detail matches. This includes verifying important terms such as rent amounts, security deposits, lease duration, renewal rights, and any negotiated amendments. By identifying and correcting discrepancies before you sign the document, your lawyer helps you avoid potential legal disputes or unfavorable terms.

Identifying Hidden Risks in an Estoppel Certificate

An experienced real estate lawyer understands the legal nuances of estoppel certificates and can identify language that could impact your rights as a tenant. For instance, vague or overly broad statements about the condition of the property or the status of disputes can expose you to future liabilities. Your lawyer can discuss these problematic terms with your landlord and suggest revisions if needed to protect your interests.

Ensuring Your Rights Are Accurately Documented

Your rights as a tenant including lease renewal options, subleasing permissions, or exclusive use clauses must be clearly stated in the estoppel certificate. Your lawyer can review these provisions, make sure they are aligned with the terms of your original lease agreement, and safeguard your right to enforce them with current or future landlords.

Clarifying Ongoing Disputes and Obligations By Examining the Estoppel Certificate and Other Documents

If there are unresolved disputes or obligations between you and the landlord – such as pending repairs or concessions – your lawyer can make sure that these are documented in the estoppel certificate. It can prevent a new landlord or property owner from denying their responsibility to address these issues.

Negotiating Revisions When Necessary

If the estoppel certificate includes unfavorable terms or omits important details, your lawyer can negotiate with the landlord or buyer to revise the document. This ensures that the final certificate accurately reflects your rights and the current lease terms before you sign.

Advising on Legal Consequences

Signing an estoppel certificate has legal consequences that could affect your tenancy. Your lawyer can explain how the document could impact your rights and obligations and provide you with the information you need to make an informed decision.

Providing Legal Representation in Disputes 

If any disputes arise between you and the landlord regarding the terms of the estoppel certificate, your lawyer can represent you and take steps to resolve these issues through negotiation, mediation, or litigation if required.

Protect Your Tenant Rights with Our Knowledgeable California Real Estate Attorneys

Estoppel certificates are more than just routine paperwork. They are legally binding documents that can impact your rights and interests as a tenant. At Garmo & Garmo, we understand the complexities of these agreements and the risks they pose to tenants. Whether you are leasing office space, retail property, or an industrial facility, our experienced real estate attorneys are here to protect your interests.

We can carefully review your estoppel certificate, compare it with your original lease, and ensure the terms are fair and do not affect your rights as a tenant in any way. From identifying discrepancies to negotiating revisions, we can provide the proactive legal support you need to avoid costly mistakes and unfavorable terms.

Call Garmo & Garmo today at 619-441-2500 or get in touch with us online to schedule a consultation with one of our skilled California real estate lawyers.